Plunge All-In leads on our weighted scoring by 0.8 points over Penguin Chillers Barrel Cold Therapy Package. Penguin Chillers Barrel Cold Therapy Package costs $6,440 less — about 75% — so the question is whether what Plunge All-In adds is worth that to you. They separate most on price (Penguin Chillers Barrel Cold Therapy Package), overall score (Plunge All-In) and minimum temperature (Penguin Chillers Barrel Cold Therapy Package) — those are the rows worth reading closely. In short: Plunge All-In for all-in-one cold and contrast therapy with minimal upkeep; Penguin Chillers Barrel Cold Therapy Package for ice Barrel owners ready to stop buying ice.
| 2 products | ![]() Penguin Chillers Penguin Chillers Barrel Cold Therapy Package | ![]() Plunge Plunge All-In |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $2,199.99 | $8,640 |
| Overall score | 7.7 | 8.5 |
| Minimum temperature (°F) | 37 °F (maintains low-to-mid 40s °F) | 37 °F |
| Chiller (HP) | — | 1.0 HP |
| Capacity (people) | — | 1 person |
| Water volume (gal) | No tub included — sized for Ice Barrel 300/400/500 | ~100 gal |
| Filtration | 150-micron washable/reusable filter plus inline debris screen | 20-micron filter |
| Sanitation | None — ozone venturi explicitly not compatible | Ozone |
| Noise (dB) | 56 dBA sound rating | ~55 dB |
| Electrical | 110-120V single phase, 450W, 3.9A, 6 ft cord | 110V |
We may earn a commission when you purchase through links on our site. This does not influence our scoring methodology or recommendations.
Penguin Chillers
Best for Ice Barrel owners ready to stop buying ice
Plunge
Best for All-in-one cold and contrast therapy with minimal upkeep